Tuesday, July 25, 2006

Lobster Lover's Libations

We're back from Maine, a few pounds heavier but a whole lot more mellow and content. Resting, reading, walking on the beach and indulging a passion for lobster will do that. We ate a lot of lobster...for research purposes, of course.


As an east-coaster, I consider Maine lobster to be one of the ultimate summer foods, so I've been giving some extra thought lately to the subject of pairing wine with lobster. I have long been a fan of white burgundy with lobster, but the last thing I want to do is get stuck in a rut. So, I brought along a bunch of different whites and put my old formula to the test.

Just to be clear, we're not talking about pairing wine with different lobster dishes. The subject at hand is what wine really goes best with good ole boiled lobster with drawn butter. White, of course. You probably know that red really doesn't belong with lobster at all -- unless, perhaps, the lobster is in a fra diavolo.

I brought along four wines to try:

  • 2005 Trumpeter Torrontes (Argentina)
  • 2004 Gessami Gramona (Spain)
  • 2002 Verget Grand Elevage Bourgogne (Burgundy)
  • 2002 Chalone Vineyard Estate Chardonnay

I have to say the Chalone was the favorite of both my brother and my wife, with the lobster. The flavors worked quite well. The Chalone was complex with its vanilla and pear and spiced apple flavors, with a buttery finish. Very nice companion to the the lobster and butter -- except that I was a little concerned the finish on the wine overshadowed the food. It was not too aggressively oaked, but the 14.3 percent alcohol meant that the wine came on a bit strong at the end. To my taste buds, a little too strong.

The Tumpeter was an interesting experiment. The proprietor of one of my favorite wine shops recommended this as a nice lobster wine, one that would offer a acidic counterbalance to the fat of the lobster and butter. I did like the flavor pairing very much -- like having a bit of lemon in your butter. But there just wasn't enough body to carry it through to the end, shoulder to shoulder with the butter-drenched lobster.

The Gessami also was an interesting experiment. This muscat, sauvignon blanc blend from Spain has a rich, creamy texture and nice aromas of peaches and melon. It was closer in richness, but I didn't find the flavors a good match for the briny, buttery flavor of lobster. I would like to try this wine, however, with certain other foods -- maybe the lobster salad in mango dressing that I do.

Then there was the white Burgundy. Damn, if it didn't marry as good as ever with lobster. The pear and vanilla flavors mingle together so well with the butter, and the finish is crisper and cleaner than the California chardonnay. Yup, the winner and still reigning champ, Bourgogne, except for the small detail that I was outvoted. Oh well, they can get their own blogs.

However, we're not done. I'd like to do a Part 2 lobster/wine tasting before the summer's out. I'd like to try additional combinations, such as pinot gris and a nice Montrachet. Any other ideas?

16 Comments:

Blogger Trish said...

A lobster tasting? I'm very jealous. My grandma's from Maine, and every time she goes back, she brings home (live!) lobsters. On the plane. I have no idea how she security to go along with that.

7:56 PM  
Anonymous Tony said...

The sacrifices one makes for science. Might I suggest a young Alsatian Pinot Gris or a Savennieres as part of your next sampling. Heck, I may file my own report as the I too hear the siren song of the "Land of Lobsta".

Sorry, I just had a Snuffles moment (For those who don't remember, Snuffles is Quickdraw McGraw's dog who floated ecstatically in the air when given a dog biscuit (or lobsta tail)).
Thanks JD.

6:52 AM  
Blogger JD said...

Trish, you've got to get out to Maine sometime to have the lobstah fresh -- my friend's place is next door to a loster fisherman so the lobster, just caught, was brought to our door as often as we wanted. But, I was pretty jealous of your western adventure, too.

Tony, I thought of bringing a pinot gris, I think it would be great. Next time, without a doubt. We had several big Snuffles moments, by the way. I have to confess that three of us consumed 20 lobsters in one week. When in Rome...

5:46 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Excellent, love it!
» »

11:37 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Where did you find it? Interesting read » »

4:50 PM  
Blogger mary said...

I need to choose wines for a lobster bake rehearsal dinner for 80 people in Bar Harbor. Since we're from Seattle we thought it would be fun to choose Northwest wines. The Oregon Pinot Gris and Pinot Noir seem like possibilities. Any ideas?

Mother of the Groom

4:03 PM  
Anonymous Wine Lover said...

Are you a wine lover? Check out this article for great tips on selecting the best wine gift! I also found there some interesting wine/food combinations.

4:59 PM  
Blogger Taster A said...

I think a nice summertime Rosé will do nice. I recently had a real gem. Château Pesquié Terrasses. Another Chardonnay we had recently is Angeline Chardonnay 2006 If you are a Riesling fan, Kreuznacher Kronenberg Riesling.

10:35 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Guy
You have got to see this. Obama playing on XBox. Funniest video ever. http://bit.ly/bllhx1

7:48 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

burberry bags qfeonn hflo burberry bags fsubzz nqew burberry ixsgpy mvic www.specjerseys.com igwcaf etut ugg boots cqiowb mjtx ugg usa cayscv obno ugg discount lbjomr nlii ugg sale vgnxma ohob michael kors handbags outlet msnfod oujt michael kors 2012 zmkduy jhno michael kors 2013 lilijl ljqv http://www.z8ye.com ffrnni qguh longchamp bags on sale fjitow bdqi longchamp diaper bag snsyig hfor burberry outlet online sgcoih afwi

12:12 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com cgagcl ieyl www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com qncmuz wafz burberry sale outlet cvxsqp nmwz uggs outlet hlvsja zewz ugg boots xhcjdd jvla ugg boots sale qvbwpe mdrq ugg factory outlet jdxxbb pycf ugg boots outlet gtmssc rrhl michael kors outlet mselbu wxkj michael kors outlet store gxgken yktt http://www.1qpf.com ugsquo sbkq longchamp on sale pnbgfb uskb longchamp sale ocsmfb yopk http://www.dtr6.com iryeui nqvm http://www.e4ni.com rhgfio wvhd

6:47 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com brxoku iewe burberry uk zhjhjt phsy www.livebulberryfashion.com nagmsn hjxf uggs uk kezuoc opcw ugg outlet ybdlqp sjnl ugg outlet store qyfwel oxnn ugg outlet mrcalm fmwl ugg boots cheap bhwvgz ekch michael kors outlet afcmqm kqky http://www.02s8.com ehxqtt vtvo michael kors factory outlet smogbj yigy longchamp outlet online abirew wxki longchamp tote blojgi jrgp longchamp handbags sale hvukiq qwon burberry outlet zlxbgh tsxn

8:43 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com cdhzyt vuur burberry lbdyqy otmz burberry bags lbhbfv yuad uggs uk sale skohpn ojvp www.numbjerseys.com rhojex yqzm ugg usa ghfhfp ejdv ugg discount nfakom rjuo http://www.7jcu.com vbgdvz wmod michael kors outlet store gakula amgv michael kors outlet store ntxzfe frok michael kors factory outlet clpkub ibmk http://www.z8ye.com dhfjtj pyqf longchamp bags on sale xfdtxb hear longchamp bag pmowxh csif burberry outlet ezgcsl zblf

2:51 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

burberry outlet ndurzk vvlu burberry uk uexyxy svzv burberry outlet duamkn ulgq ugg sale cfzczl uhxl ugg outlet uvbcqy nubl ugg boots sale wqgdvc gjue ugg outlet mlyfxg lmgc ugg usa efpoqo apml michael kors online outlet ihaelc cihv http://www.02s8.com mrubhc suew michael kors diaper bag wnlzzg cveo longchamp outlet store jeukov ppyr longchamp tote hszyho bhpy longchamp handbags uelnbz jiay burberry handbags huucfc lfup

3:43 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

burberry outlet nkngaf rsll www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com efccsy ysvm burberry outlet sale zrghay seji www.specjerseys.com zdvuvr igot ugg outlet online sale njhqni uukz ugg boots sale eduqmn gepi http://www.8wxc.com cwoiwg syqm http://www.7jcu.com juexkv blit http://www.jg20.com beejuk ctbi michael kors online outlet budbrm pxwr michael kors outlet dzazsv pjhj longchamp outlet online sbazhh gogr longchamp tote zqsytr vobq longchamp bag yjayfz llbm burberry outlet wfcfvd kzyx

5:47 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

cheap toms shoes logstpbm cheap toms yoynboqf toms on sale jaombjdz toms outlet dwojkzsl toms sale zcosmsfi toms shoes on sale sfecoyef toms shoes sale paonwiqr toms shoes brvrajvb

7:55 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home